Review: Darkdawn (Nevernight Chronicle #3)

Review: Darkdawn (Nevernight Chronicle #3)

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Genre: Fantasy Rating: 9/10

Impressions: Gut-wrenching, climactic, emotional rollercoaster

Jay Kristoff know how to break hearts.

Darkdawn is a book that will give you all the feels. It will either make you rage, or cry, or want to prop your eyes open with tiny matchsticks, or all three. Either way you won’t get out unscathed, but that’s just part of it’s appeal.

I’ve been a fan of Kristoff since his Lotus Wars series launched in 2012, and have followed his work closely since. Having read all his books, I feel well placed to say that this one doesn’t disappoint. Putting down one of Kristoff’s books is always an effort, and flipping the final page always makes my stomach flip in a way that that most books just can’t. Like all his books, Darkdawn will make you invested. There’s no way to explain it other than that you can’t help but care about the characters, and I think this is because they are so believable and relatable as people. There’s something real and imperfect and altogether human about the characters Kristoff creates, and it’s really refreshing to experience as a reader. This coupled with his dark imagination makes for a winning combination.

I loved the sense of suspense and tension that Darkdawn created. It’s littered with twists and turns that will take you further and further down a wonderful rabbit hole where nothing exists in black and white. If I could pick at one thing, I would say the romance and focus on sexual attraction was a little overdone. It definitely was essential to the story and the progression and motivations of the lead character, but sometimes was focused on too heavily. That being said, I find it impressive that the Nevernight Chronicles are sustained by love and violence interchangeably, it’s an interesting duo.

As a protagonist, Mia is pretty memorable as an all around badass. She’s more vengeful vigilante than hero, and makes some pretty questionable choices. Yet she’s so full of conviction and strength you can’t help but love her as a lead character. In this final book especially, you really get a sense of her struggle to not only survive, but also to be someone that she herself can live with. Kristoff has spoken about how he believes the best characters are those that want something with all their being, but can only get it in a roundabout way that they don’t expect, and usually through sacrificing something else. Brienne of Tarth is a perfect example of this, and now, so is Mia Corvere.

Review: The Blue Rose

Review: The Blue Rose

Rating: 3 out of 5.

Genre: Historical Fiction, romance Rating: 6.5/10

Impressions: Robust plot, cliche romance

Blue Rose gave me the distinct impression that I was living vicariously through its characters to experience the French Revolution. The violent fall of the French monarchy is not a pretty sight to behold, and Forsyth makes no apologies for this, instead she seems to revel in it. There’s an honesty and a bluntness in her writing which gives it all the more impact, and I often felt as though I was looking at something I shouldn’t be, and yet couldn’t look away.

The story fluctuates between beautiful and gruesome, tumultuous and pensive, but maintains a fast pace throughout. It’s interesting to witness the clear contrast between the higher and lower classes, the rising tensions sparked by dissent, and the stirrings of revolution. Blue rose poses interesting ethical questions like: what does justice look like? Can vengeance do good? Is violence acceptable if it creates change? But most importantly, I think it really succeeds in humanising historical figures such as Marie-Antoinette and Louis XVI, before and during their fall. Seeing the Reign of Terror in this light makes feelings of sadness, empathy and horror unavoidable.

The historical aspects of this novel and the movement of the plot created a page-turner of a book, but it was let down by the romance. I have no qualms with romance in fiction, or with the star-crossed lovers of Blue Rose – French aristocrat Vivianne and Welsh gardener David – but their relationship seemed one-dimensional. Over the five-year period of the novel, there’s an incessant pining for a love lost, however the love itself fell flat. For me, the relationship between Vivianne and David seemed brief and underdeveloped, and didn’t create a passion that would believably be felt for five years. I wanted them to be together for the pure fact that Vivianne was so desperately unhappy, isolated and deserving of love, but what was between her and David seemed more like puppy love than the real thing. It needed to be built upon at the outset and given more depth to successfuly carry through the whole novel.

It was frustrating to read some beautifully crafted sentences directly followed by cliches, but overall this was an entertaining read and the positives outweighed the negatives. It gets a 3.5/5 for me and i’ll be looking into what other works Forsyth has to offer.

Book rankings 2019

Book rankings 2019

Which books come out on top?

  1. Darkdawn (The Nevernight Chronicle #3), Jay Kristoff
  2. Equal Rites (Witches #1), Terry Pratchett
  3. The Last Unicorn, Peter S. Beagle
  4. The Colour of Magic, Terry Pratchett
  5. The Republic of Thieves, Scott Lynch
  6. Aurora Rising (Aurora Cycle #1), Jay Kristoff and Amie Kauffman
  7. Dev1iat3 (Lifelike #2), Jay Kristoff
  8. Assassin’s Quest (Farseer Trilogy #3), Robin Hobb
  9. Way of Kings, Brandon Sanderson
  10. Dance Dance Dance, Haruki Murakami
  11. Witches Abroad (Witches #3) Terry Pratchett
  12. Underdog, Markus Zusak
  13. The Light Fantastic, Terry Pratchett
  14. A Wizard of Earthsea (The Earthsea Quartet #1), Ursula Le Guin
  15. The Priory of the Orange Tree, Samantha Shannon
  16. After Dark, Haruki Murakami
  17. Convenience Store Woman, Sayaka Murata
  18. Any Ordinary Day, Leigh Sales
  19. Skyward, Brandon Sanderson
  20. Cradle to Cradle, William McDonough
  21. The Story of Tomoda and Matsunaga, Jun’ichiro Tanizaki  
  22. Cats Cradle, Kurt Vonnegut
  23. Lord of Souls (Elder Scrolls #2), Greg Keyes
  24. The Eternal City (Elder Scrolls #1) Greg Keyes
  25. Legion Lies of the Beholder, Brandon Sanderson
  26. The Fork the Witch and the Worm, Christopher Paolini
  27. Early Riser, Jasper Fforde
  28. Milkman, Anna Burns
  29. Pink Mountain on Locust Island, Jamie Marina Lau
  30. The Changeling, Kenzaburo Oe